MachineGhost wrote:
stone wrote:
It has to be stressed that the author isn't advocating government management. He is saying that it ISN'T the answer. He is advocating a system such as Mayo clinic. That's apparently a system where the doctors take responsibility over ensuring that patients get the most effective care, avoiding financial incentives that conflict with that.
The problem with medicine is that the customer is not in a position to themselves know what is best. They are at the mercy of the doctors because only the doctor knows what's what. The doctors have to take on board that responsibility.
Huh? You mean the doctor needs to take on that responsibility instead of the insurance companies? Because due to the Internet, patients are very informed now and know as much as or more than a doctor does about treating their own conditions. Only the uninformed poor (or the dying old farts of the Greatest Generation) are still in that stereotypical naive/ignorant "worship all authority" category. Maybe it is different in the UK where medical mediocrity is socially universal due to the NHS. Here, you can still find pockets of above averageness. To quote Buffett again, "Competition is a wonderful thing."
The only problem with the Mayo model is you won't get offered the widest range of possible options only what fits within the prevailing orthodoxy which is still based on a Big Pharma business model. But it is a huge step in the right direction. It's just not being replicated very fast because it is bad for business. 99% of doctors that stick through the first year of medical school stay because of the money not because they are humanitarians.
MachineGhost, I agree that it is now possible for many people to find out lots from the internet but I also know how hard I have found it to make appropriate judgments about my own medical conditions. Years ago I had non-hodgkins lymphoma -it scared me senseless. Looking back, I think I would have been a total sucker for someone wanting to proffer expensive, inappropriate treatments. I'm not saying patients shouldn't inform themselves, I'm just saying that it is important to recognize that they are a vulnerable group that needs expert help.
I work in a lab and often work with doctors who are branching out into doing lab based research for the first time. They lack the hands-on expertise for lab work and I can help them out with that as they find their feet. Likewise a doctor who sees lymphoma patients all day every day is going to have a much better grasp of the situation than I did with my panicky internet reading.
That said - I have interfered with my own medical treatment. When I had non-hodgkins lymphoma I said I didn't want to delay a chemo session when I had a low neutrophil count but instead wanted GCSF treatment so that I could stay on the chemo course -they went along with that request of mine.
Another occasion when I interfered with my medical treatment was when I had mania and psychosis and the medical advice was to take olanzapine. I asked to try and get better without taking it and they let me.
I have no idea whether in either case my intervention made my medical care better or worse. My guess is that in the case of the GCSF, I just made it more expensive but perhaps improved the odds of it working. In the case of the olanzapine I really have no idea -so far, fingers crossed, I seemed to have done fine without having taken it -but perhaps I was just lucky.
-I just think it is worth keeping a balanced view and to try and make the most of your doctors' expertise.
Another quote from that first article:
The third class of health-cost proposals, I explained, would push people to use medical savings accounts and hold high-deductible insurance policies: “They’d have more of their own money on the line, and that’d drive them to bargain with you and other surgeons, right?”?
He gave me a quizzical look. We tried to imagine the scenario. A cardiologist tells an elderly woman that she needs bypass surgery and has Dr. Dyke see her. They discuss the blockages in her heart, the operation, the risks. And now they’re supposed to haggle over the price as if he were selling a rug in a souk? “I’ll do three vessels for thirty thousand, but if you take four I’ll throw in an extra night in the I.C.U.”?—that sort of thing? Dyke shook his head. “Who comes up with this stuff?”? he asked. “Any plan that relies on the sheep to negotiate with the wolves is doomed to failure.”?
"Good judgment comes from experience. Experience comes from bad judgment." - Mulla Nasrudin