Page 1 of 1
Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Sat Nov 15, 2014 10:43 pm
by Benko
http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Peace/2014 ... t-Heard-Of
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On November 30th, Swiss voters will go to the polls to reassert their historical position of backing their country’s currency with gold. Info is here:
http://gold-initiative.ch/ which is german but google translate says it is already in english
If approved, the “Save Our Swiss Gold”? initiative will force three very uncomfortable mandates on the Swiss National Bank and the rest of the Fiat world.
The Swiss National Bank will NOT have the right to sell its gold reserves.
The Swiss National Bank must hold at LEAST 20% of its total assets in gold.
The gold of the Swiss National Bank must be stored PHYSICALLY in Switzerland.
For the outsiders, the real fun will come in the next few weeks while we watch these same Swiss government officials try to explain why restoring a sound currency, that served them very well for hundreds of years, is now a very bad idea
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Sun Nov 16, 2014 9:28 am
by Reub
I hope that it passes to serve as an example for other countries. If this does pass and Switzerland is forced to buy and hold a latge amount of gold, could this be the catalyst that starts the price of gold rising?
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Sun Nov 16, 2014 11:49 am
by WiseOne
Maybe!
Not to mention that something very interesting will happen to PRPFX, with all those Swiss francs it's holding. I assume that the franc will be uncoupled to the Euro if this initiative passes.
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Sun Nov 16, 2014 12:25 pm
by moda0306
I love natural experiments in economics... this should be fun to observe, no matter what your current opinion is on the mater of hard vs fiat currencies.
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Sun Nov 16, 2014 3:21 pm
by Tortoise
Even if the Swiss go back to a gold-backed currency, how will that make a big difference in the rest of the world? The Swiss used a gold-backed currency before, and it didn't stop the rest of the world from going fiat. It's a tiny country with a tiny population and a tiny economy.
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Sun Nov 16, 2014 7:27 pm
by Ad Orientem
Unless I misread the actual proposition, the author seems to misunderstand what's going on. I believe the referendum has nothing to do with backing the Franc with gold. But rather specifies that a certain percentage of foreign currency reserves need to be held in the form of gold. That's a long jump from a gold standard.
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Sun Nov 16, 2014 7:33 pm
by Benko
Ad Orientem wrote:
Unless I misread the actual proposition, the author seems to misunderstand what's going on. I believe the referendum has nothing to do with backing the Franc with gold. But rather specifies that a certain percentage of foreign currency reserves need to be held in the form of gold. That's a long jump from a gold standard.
Dang, if you use bing to translate, it looks like you are correct. No habla Deutsch to watch the videos and check.
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Sun Nov 16, 2014 9:13 pm
by MachineGhost
Reub wrote:
I hope that it passes to serve as an example for other countries. If this does pass and Switzerland is forced to buy and hold a latge amount of gold, could this be the catalyst that starts the price of gold rising?
You nailed it!
But it could be a fake out. Bottoms are formed with people throwing in the towel, so maybe the referendum NOT passing would actually be the catalyst.
If the referendum passes, the SNB will have to buy about $60 billion worth of gold in Swiss Francs to get up to 20%.
[img width=700]
http://i61.tinypic.com/f0nqlx.png[/img]
Patience is a virture.
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Mon Nov 17, 2014 11:05 am
by dragoncar
MachineGhost wrote:
If the referendum passes, the SNB will have to buy about $60 billion worth of gold in Swiss Francs to get up to 20%.
The most interesting thing is what it will really cost to buy the gold -- shouldn't the cost of gold in Francs go down as their gold holdings increase? In the edge case where they commit to buying 100% in gold, it should barely "cost" them anything, as the Franc should strengthen to the price of gold..... right?
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Mon Nov 17, 2014 11:22 am
by Ad Orientem
dragoncar wrote:
MachineGhost wrote:
If the referendum passes, the SNB will have to buy about $60 billion worth of gold in Swiss Francs to get up to 20%.
The most interesting thing is what it will really cost to buy the gold -- shouldn't the cost of gold in Francs go down as their gold holdings increase? In the edge case where they commit to buying 100% in gold, it should barely "cost" them anything, as the Franc should strengthen to the price of gold..... right?
Why would this happen? As I noted above, the Swiss are not voting to back the Franc with Gold. This is about foreign currency reserves at the central bank.
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Mon Nov 17, 2014 1:00 pm
by dragoncar
Ad Orientem wrote:
dragoncar wrote:
MachineGhost wrote:
If the referendum passes, the SNB will have to buy about $60 billion worth of gold in Swiss Francs to get up to 20%.
The most interesting thing is what it will really cost to buy the gold -- shouldn't the cost of gold in Francs go down as their gold holdings increase? In the edge case where they commit to buying 100% in gold, it should barely "cost" them anything, as the Franc should strengthen to the price of gold..... right?
Why would this happen? As I noted above, the Swiss are not voting to back the Franc with Gold. This is about foreign currency reserves at the central bank.
I suspect they think it will happen -- otherwise what is their motivation for increasing reserves?
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Mon Nov 17, 2014 2:28 pm
by Ad Orientem
dragoncar wrote:
Ad Orientem wrote:
dragoncar wrote:
The most interesting thing is what it will really cost to buy the gold -- shouldn't the cost of gold in Francs go down as their gold holdings increase? In the edge case where they commit to buying 100% in gold, it should barely "cost" them anything, as the Franc should strengthen to the price of gold..... right?
Why would this happen? As I noted above, the Swiss are not voting to back the Franc with Gold. This is about foreign currency reserves at the central bank.
I suspect they think it will happen -- otherwise what is their motivation for increasing reserves?
As far as I can tell the referendum is being pushed by a far right political party. Last I heard it was trailing rather badly in polls.
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Mon Nov 17, 2014 7:23 pm
by MachineGhost
Ad Orientem wrote:
As far as I can tell the referendum is being pushed by a far right political party. Last I heard it was trailing rather badly in polls.

Interesting. What was the rationale for selling off the gold reserves circa 2001? Switzerland doesn't strike me as a statist welfare state where they would have needed fiat spending.
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Thu Nov 20, 2014 3:31 pm
by Libertarian666
WiseOne wrote:
Maybe!
Not to mention that something very interesting will happen to PRPFX, with all those Swiss francs it's holding. I assume that the franc will be uncoupled to the Euro if this initiative passes.
I can't imagine how they could keep the CHF coupled to the Euro if it passes.
I have quite a lot of CHF in my portfolio, so I'd obviously be happy to see it pass just for that reason, but also because it would be a poke in the eye to the "pure" fiat paper money crowd.
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Fri Nov 28, 2014 5:58 pm
by MachineGhost
The central bank can just sell off its US and Euro currency reserves to get up to 20%; there's no gold buying needed.
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Sun Nov 30, 2014 1:56 pm
by clacy
This measure was voted down convincingly
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Sun Nov 30, 2014 2:16 pm
by Ad Orientem
clacy wrote:
This measure was voted down convincingly
Thank God. Everyone was fixating on the requirement to hold 20% of the central banks reserves in gold. But they ignored the killer clause. The referendum prohibited the central bank from ever selling any of its gold. That's insane. When you start with 20% in gold, but can never sell any, that means that overtime you are going to wind up with gold constituting more and more of your reserves with no ability to do anything with it.
It was an idiotic proposal, as anyone except the most fanatical gold bugs could see. I would have voted against it first thing in the morning and twice after lunch.
Re: Swiss voting whether to go back to gold based currency
Posted: Sun Nov 30, 2014 7:05 pm
by MachineGhost
Now maybe the bottom will be in after the capitulation selling.
The vote was 22% for, 78% against.