Re: Canadian PP?
Posted: Tue Jan 28, 2014 12:59 pm
good thread! some other suggestions:
Cash - Altamira high-interest savings - 1.25% without any interest rate risk. I use CLF also but it can and does lose money with rate fluctuations.
Gold - Horizons Comex Gold (HUG) - tracks price of gold in US dollars, lower MER than IGT. As far as I know IGT has a 0.8% MER. Also HUG is commission-free at my broker (Qtrade).
Long-term bonds - Powershares Ultra DLUX Long Term Government Bond (PGL). This is not quite as super-premium as ZFL, it does own some provincial debt (mostly federal though). However I like it for several reasons:
1) ZFL has been messing around with the allocation lately. They own Canada housing corporation debt and a lot of infrastructure projects like Muskrat Falls in Newfoundland. They also have quite a bit of Canada Post debt which I don't like.
2) It tracks a different index which I like better. PGL tracks DEX Ultra DLUX government bond, which has very large requirements (e.g. minimum bond issue $1bn). ZFL tracks FTSE TMX Canada Long Term Federal Bond Index which has a much smaller scale (minimum $50m) although to be fair ZFL has a stricter credit rating requirement.
3) It has much higher trading volume (9x as large as ZFL).
In terms of weighted average duration, yield and MER it's pretty much the same as ZFL.
International stocks
iShares Europe Australasia Far East (EAFE) (XEF) - for people like me who aren't comfortable with emerging market volatility and want vanilla international stocks. Holds international blue-chips like Toyota, Diageo, Daimler, SAP, Mitsubishi, etc.
iShares emerging market (XEC) - exposure to emerging market (mostly Korea, Taiwan, Russia).
I used to use iShares International Fundamental Index (CIE) and iShares Emerging Markets (XEM) but the MERs were too high, there are better alternatives.
Canadian stocks
Horizons TSX 60 index (HXT) - absolute cheapest way to own TSX index I've found (0.07% MER).
BMO low volatility (ZLB). I am agnostic on low-volatility investing but this is much more diversified than a TSX 60 index fund. Much less financials and resources, more consumer defensive and utilities. Top components of TSX are 1) Royal Bank 2) TD bank 3) Scotiabank and although I own the index I get uncomfortable with too much bank exposure. Top holding of ZLB are Couche-Tarde, Metro Grocery, Dollarama. Also has a higher dividend than the TSX (2.2%).
My modified PP is very similar to Gosso's:
20% gold
20% cash/short term debt
25% long-term debt
10% US stocks
10% International Stocks
15% Canadian stocks
Cash - Altamira high-interest savings - 1.25% without any interest rate risk. I use CLF also but it can and does lose money with rate fluctuations.
Gold - Horizons Comex Gold (HUG) - tracks price of gold in US dollars, lower MER than IGT. As far as I know IGT has a 0.8% MER. Also HUG is commission-free at my broker (Qtrade).
Long-term bonds - Powershares Ultra DLUX Long Term Government Bond (PGL). This is not quite as super-premium as ZFL, it does own some provincial debt (mostly federal though). However I like it for several reasons:
1) ZFL has been messing around with the allocation lately. They own Canada housing corporation debt and a lot of infrastructure projects like Muskrat Falls in Newfoundland. They also have quite a bit of Canada Post debt which I don't like.
2) It tracks a different index which I like better. PGL tracks DEX Ultra DLUX government bond, which has very large requirements (e.g. minimum bond issue $1bn). ZFL tracks FTSE TMX Canada Long Term Federal Bond Index which has a much smaller scale (minimum $50m) although to be fair ZFL has a stricter credit rating requirement.
3) It has much higher trading volume (9x as large as ZFL).
In terms of weighted average duration, yield and MER it's pretty much the same as ZFL.
International stocks
iShares Europe Australasia Far East (EAFE) (XEF) - for people like me who aren't comfortable with emerging market volatility and want vanilla international stocks. Holds international blue-chips like Toyota, Diageo, Daimler, SAP, Mitsubishi, etc.
iShares emerging market (XEC) - exposure to emerging market (mostly Korea, Taiwan, Russia).
I used to use iShares International Fundamental Index (CIE) and iShares Emerging Markets (XEM) but the MERs were too high, there are better alternatives.
Canadian stocks
Horizons TSX 60 index (HXT) - absolute cheapest way to own TSX index I've found (0.07% MER).
BMO low volatility (ZLB). I am agnostic on low-volatility investing but this is much more diversified than a TSX 60 index fund. Much less financials and resources, more consumer defensive and utilities. Top components of TSX are 1) Royal Bank 2) TD bank 3) Scotiabank and although I own the index I get uncomfortable with too much bank exposure. Top holding of ZLB are Couche-Tarde, Metro Grocery, Dollarama. Also has a higher dividend than the TSX (2.2%).
My modified PP is very similar to Gosso's:
20% gold
20% cash/short term debt
25% long-term debt
10% US stocks
10% International Stocks
15% Canadian stocks