Solution for those on the fence between bogle or browne
Moderator: Global Moderator
-
- Executive Member
- Posts: 689
- Joined: Mon Oct 01, 2012 7:32 pm
Re: Solution for those on the fence between bogle or browne
Hahah half 60/40-half HBPP. I dig it. For my kids' 529s I just do the Vanguard target date funds - accurate to their age. I thought it's not the end of the world to rely a bit on conventional wisdom.
42.5 US TSM
20 ITT
12.5 LTT
12.5 STT
12.5 Gold
That said... it wouldn't be a big step to take that portfolio and go to the golden butterfly - just break up the TSM in half and barbell the ITT and you're there (albeit slightly underweight gold).
Then again I'm a 1/N weirdo.
42.5 US TSM
20 ITT
12.5 LTT
12.5 STT
12.5 Gold
That said... it wouldn't be a big step to take that portfolio and go to the golden butterfly - just break up the TSM in half and barbell the ITT and you're there (albeit slightly underweight gold).
Then again I'm a 1/N weirdo.
1/n weirdo. US-TSM, US-SCV, Intl-SCV, LTT, STT, GLD (+ a little in MF)
- Kriegsspiel
- Executive Member
- Posts: 4043
- Joined: Sun Sep 16, 2012 5:28 pm
Re: Solution for those on the fence between bogle or browne
The author says that "never before has this portfolio behaved so badly" than 2022, and then just says "use options and bitcoin/eth" to make it not behave so badly? BTC/ETH got slaughtered in 2022.
And as for him who lacks the courage to defend even his own soul: Let him not brag of his progressive views, boast of his status as an academician or a recognized artist, a distinguished citizen or general. Let him say to himself plainly: I am cattle, I am a coward, I seek only warmth and to eat my fill.
Solzhenitsyn, Live Not By Lies
Solzhenitsyn, Live Not By Lies
Re: Solution for those on the fence between bogle or browne
Alternatively what I have been thinking of but never did is Instead of a 50/50 Bogle/PP to do leveraged PP instead? If there is one portfolio on which leverage should not be too risky, it should be the PP? And a moderate leverage could bring the average long term return to the level (equity) investors are comfortable with but with still a lower volatility and a neutral view on the future instead of betting on prosperity as the economic scenario.
Re: Solution for those on the fence between bogle or browne
You might enjoy threads like this one - https://gyroscopicinvesting.com/forum/v ... =10&t=9310
Let 2023 be the year of LASAGNE
Re: Solution for those on the fence between bogle or browne
Leverage just tends to broadly scale volatility, not overall broad rewards. That said, I prefer a leveraged PP as for me its more tax efficient. Short treasuries (cash and LTT) i.e. sell them, to add more stock/gold.
I get lending to the treasury, buying treasuries, when money was gold. Lend that gold to the state/King, be paid interest such that when the loan was repaid you held more gold than before. Nowadays, fiat currency since the 1930's, and you need to sell gold to lend money to the treasury and all-told upon maturity/repayment and you re-acquire gold you could very well end up with less ounces of gold than you held before.
For me the extra yearly volatility isn't a issue, as I'm not looking to lump all-in or all-out at a single point in time.
PV
As a UK based investor, Pounds in UK home, US dollars invested in US stock, gold non-fiat global currency is broad enough currency and asset diversity. As well as reduced counter-party risk (house and gold in-hand). Similar to what the Talmud advocated millennia ago.
Dislike the concept of lending fiat currency (buying treasuries) to a entity that can print/spend (induce inflation), dictates the interest and taxation rates, can change the rules. Seems much like lending to a dodgy car lot dealer to me.
For drawdown there's no need to rebalance between stocks and gold, just drawing your income from whichever is the most higher valued at the time is enough. There's no purchase tax on British legal tender gold coins, nor are there any taxes on sale. Similar to old copper penny coins where you weren't taxed on copper price increases when 'selling' coins. So stocks in tax exempt account, physical gold coins, bought once, sold piecemeal (income withdrawals if the value of gold is greater than the value of stocks). Your primary home is exempt from capital gains taxation when sold, nor is imputed rent benefit taxed, the rent that would otherwise have to be found/paid.
I get lending to the treasury, buying treasuries, when money was gold. Lend that gold to the state/King, be paid interest such that when the loan was repaid you held more gold than before. Nowadays, fiat currency since the 1930's, and you need to sell gold to lend money to the treasury and all-told upon maturity/repayment and you re-acquire gold you could very well end up with less ounces of gold than you held before.
For me the extra yearly volatility isn't a issue, as I'm not looking to lump all-in or all-out at a single point in time.
PV
As a UK based investor, Pounds in UK home, US dollars invested in US stock, gold non-fiat global currency is broad enough currency and asset diversity. As well as reduced counter-party risk (house and gold in-hand). Similar to what the Talmud advocated millennia ago.
Dislike the concept of lending fiat currency (buying treasuries) to a entity that can print/spend (induce inflation), dictates the interest and taxation rates, can change the rules. Seems much like lending to a dodgy car lot dealer to me.
For drawdown there's no need to rebalance between stocks and gold, just drawing your income from whichever is the most higher valued at the time is enough. There's no purchase tax on British legal tender gold coins, nor are there any taxes on sale. Similar to old copper penny coins where you weren't taxed on copper price increases when 'selling' coins. So stocks in tax exempt account, physical gold coins, bought once, sold piecemeal (income withdrawals if the value of gold is greater than the value of stocks). Your primary home is exempt from capital gains taxation when sold, nor is imputed rent benefit taxed, the rent that would otherwise have to be found/paid.
Re: Solution for those on the fence between bogle or browne
Not a terrible choice. If you are taking that approach have a listen to BelangP & Maneco64(?) British investor.seajay wrote: ↑Wed Jan 25, 2023 2:25 pmAs a UK based investor, Pounds in UK home, US dollars invested in US stock, gold non-fiat global currency is broad enough currency and asset diversity. As well as reduced counter-party risk (house and gold in-hand). Similar to what the Talmud advocated millennia ago.
- Attachments
-
- 55 45 Dev Wld TSM to Gold.png (127.77 KiB) Viewed 1204 times
Aussie GoldSmithPP - 25% PMGOLD, 75% VDCO
Re: Solution for those on the fence between bogle or browne
Thanks Hal
I have previously watched a few of BelangP's youtubes but do find them too lengthy for my liking, so I'm not a follower.
I have previously watched a few of BelangP's youtubes but do find them too lengthy for my liking, so I'm not a follower.
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 147
- Joined: Fri May 08, 2020 6:06 pm
Re: Solution for those on the fence between bogle or browne
Portfolio insurance! 80 stock value halves to 40, 20 gold value doubles to 40, and you have the option to sell gold to double up on the number of shares held after prices had halved (Martingale).johnnywitt wrote: ↑Thu Feb 02, 2023 2:14 pmBelangP, is basically about 80% dividend equity & 20% physical gold bullion coins.