Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
Moderator: Global Moderator
- MachineGhost
- Executive Member
- Posts: 10054
- Joined: Sat Nov 12, 2011 9:31 am
Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
So Governor "Moonbeam" actually signed legislation on this past Monday raising the minimum wage in CA to $15 by 2023. At 3% rate of inflation that will make it worth about $12 at that time.
Anyone have any ideas what is going to happen between now and then? Are fast food prices going to rise and layoffs increase due to decreased sales revenue? Will it provoke systemic inflation as more demand chases fixed supply? Or will it not make much of a dent at all as everyone adjusts?
Anyone have any ideas what is going to happen between now and then? Are fast food prices going to rise and layoffs increase due to decreased sales revenue? Will it provoke systemic inflation as more demand chases fixed supply? Or will it not make much of a dent at all as everyone adjusts?
"All generous minds have a horror of what are commonly called 'Facts'. They are the brute beasts of the intellectual domain." -- Thomas Hobbes
Disclaimer: I am not a broker, dealer, investment advisor, physician, theologian or prophet. I should not be considered as legally permitted to render such advice!
Disclaimer: I am not a broker, dealer, investment advisor, physician, theologian or prophet. I should not be considered as legally permitted to render such advice!
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
The push for automation will likely ramp up slightly faster in industries will a large amount of low paid workers.
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
I don't know how that will work out, but it will be interesting to see.
But, $12-15/hr is awfully low, considering the costs of living in NY - probably works out to somewhere around $25K/yr, depending on taxes. I can't imagine how somebody could afford to live there on one full-time income, even out of Manhattan.
Sorry, you said CA, but the same issue probably applies there - I seem to recall seeing a story that NY was doing something similar.
But, $12-15/hr is awfully low, considering the costs of living in NY - probably works out to somewhere around $25K/yr, depending on taxes. I can't imagine how somebody could afford to live there on one full-time income, even out of Manhattan.
Sorry, you said CA, but the same issue probably applies there - I seem to recall seeing a story that NY was doing something similar.
Simonjester wrote: it doesn't seem likely to have any positive effect for workers, between the staggered implementation, the already high cost of living in CA, and the fact that most min wage jobs there are already part time to avoid obama-care.. the employers will just automate, or force workers to get more done with less staff, or raise prices, or all of the above..... i don't see anybody gaining from a higher min wage
Last edited by jafs on Fri Apr 08, 2016 1:08 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
This will be great for rents in my area
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
This will kill small business in rural areas--which may, in the end, be exactly what is intended. Seems that every solution the lawmakers dream up just happens to select for the Walmarts and the Monsantos of the world. And the majority of the supposed beneficiaries of this kind of "nanny state" legislation are either too dumbed-down to figure that out or have too little skin in the game to care.
Last edited by Maddy on Fri Apr 08, 2016 3:26 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"We are on the verge of a global transformation; all we need is the. . . right major crisis. . . and the nation will accept the. . . new world order." David Rockefeller (1994)
- I Shrugged
- Executive Member
- Posts: 2064
- Joined: Tue Dec 18, 2012 6:35 pm
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
This winter, where I don't recall, my wife and I were in a McDonalds that had self-order terminals inside the store. They had regular cashiers too of course. I imagine they are testing them to reduce labor hours when $15/hour comes their way.
Stay free, my friends.
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
Of course. If you raise labor input costs companies will scamble make productivity gains. That goes for any industry. Further automation in fast food would happen regardless but it's likely to force the issue faster this way.I Shrugged wrote: This winter, where I don't recall, my wife and I were in a McDonalds that had self-order terminals inside the store. They had regular cashiers too of course. I imagine they are testing them to reduce labor hours when $15/hour comes their way.
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
The entire universe of options are:
1) eat the cost and operate at a lower margin
2) transfer the increase to consumers
3) increase productivity
4) cost out in the business
Results:
Part 1: Options 2 and 4 will be what most big box retailers will do since their scale allows for it
Part 2: Option 1 will be what most small shops have to do since they can't invest like the big guys
1) eat the cost and operate at a lower margin
2) transfer the increase to consumers
3) increase productivity
4) cost out in the business
Results:
Part 1: Options 2 and 4 will be what most big box retailers will do since their scale allows for it
Part 2: Option 1 will be what most small shops have to do since they can't invest like the big guys
“Let every man divide his money into three parts, and invest a third in land, a third in business and a third let him keep by him in reserve.� ~Talmud
- Mark Leavy
- Executive Member
- Posts: 1950
- Joined: Thu Mar 01, 2012 10:20 pm
- Location: US Citizen, Permanent Traveler
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
I listened to a great NPR "Planet Money" Podcast today. Based on the recent CA minimum wage law passing, they resurrected an old podcast where San Jose, CA raised the minimum wage from $8.00 per hour to $10.00 per hour. And then they interviewed employees and business owners at a mall that sat on the border between San Jose and Santa Clara.
Depending on which store you were in (or for Gap, which part of the store...) the minimum wage was either $8 or $10 an hour.
One store owner had a pretzel store on each end of the mall.
http://www.npr.org/podcasts/510289/planet-money
#562: A Mall Divided
They didn't cover too many issues concerning the positives and negatives of a minimum wage - but they dealt a lot with what happens when the minimum wage is not consistent.
As usual, I thought Planet Money did a pretty balanced job.
Depending on which store you were in (or for Gap, which part of the store...) the minimum wage was either $8 or $10 an hour.
One store owner had a pretzel store on each end of the mall.
http://www.npr.org/podcasts/510289/planet-money
#562: A Mall Divided
They didn't cover too many issues concerning the positives and negatives of a minimum wage - but they dealt a lot with what happens when the minimum wage is not consistent.
As usual, I thought Planet Money did a pretty balanced job.
- Kriegsspiel
- Executive Member
- Posts: 4052
- Joined: Sun Sep 16, 2012 5:28 pm
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
California should raise the median wage too, to let the middle class in on this action.
You there, Ephialtes. May you live forever.
-
- Executive Member
- Posts: 5994
- Joined: Wed Dec 31, 1969 6:00 pm
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
Even better, they should pass a law requiring everyone to be paid more than the median wage! Why should some people get less than that?Kriegsspiel wrote: California should raise the median wage too, to let the middle class in on this action.
- Austen Heller
- Executive Member
- Posts: 154
- Joined: Tue Aug 24, 2010 6:58 pm
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
I agree with this. To give you a real-life example, I have a family member who works in a rural low-cost-of-living area of upstate NY, managing a small manufacturing business (< 30 people). Since most of the floor jobs require some skills (welding, painting, etc), they hire new people at $11/hour (which is above the current $9 minimum wage), but even the most senior people, some of whom have been there for 30 years, are maxed out at $16/hour. These are good wages for people with no education in an area of NY where it is very cheap to live. When the minimum wage goes to $15, my family member says that the final price of the product will have to go up 30%, which will kill sales, and basically kill the business. So then all these people lose their jobs and go on unemployment.Maddy wrote: This will kill small business in rural areas--which may, in the end, be exactly what is intended.
I'm not sure what is the solution here. As wages get higher, small manufacturing companies aren't going to replace workers with automated machines, they will simply close up the shop and be done.
Perhaps the minimum wages need to only be raised in larger cities, where the cost of living is higher. There is no reason to increase the wages across the entire state. This is the approach taken by Seattle. Seattle is an expensive place to live in, so $15 might make sense there, but if you're picking apples in rural WA, you can probably get by with less than $15.
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
The glory days for this country are probably long behind us. I don't see the rest of the world suddenly going back to the 40's-60's model where they paid us a premium to manufacture their stuff.
Globalization and technology have minimized the value of human capital.
Globalization and technology have minimized the value of human capital.
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
This last fall, a number of orchards in Eastern Washington let tens of thousands of pounds of fruit (mainly cherries and apples) rot on the trees. The owners couldn't afford to have them picked. These business owners run on extremely thin margins. If even one more straw is put on their backs, they will close up shop.Seattle is an expensive place to live in, so $15 might make sense there, but if you're picking apples in rural WA, you can probably get by with less than $15.
"We are on the verge of a global transformation; all we need is the. . . right major crisis. . . and the nation will accept the. . . new world order." David Rockefeller (1994)
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
What does a state really have to gain though by killing small businesses in rural areas?Austen Heller wrote:I agree with this. To give you a real-life example, I have a family member who works in a rural low-cost-of-living area of upstate NY, managing a small manufacturing business (< 30 people). Since most of the floor jobs require some skills (welding, painting, etc), they hire new people at $11/hour (which is above the current $9 minimum wage), but even the most senior people, some of whom have been there for 30 years, are maxed out at $16/hour. These are good wages for people with no education in an area of NY where it is very cheap to live. When the minimum wage goes to $15, my family member says that the final price of the product will have to go up 30%, which will kill sales, and basically kill the business. So then all these people lose their jobs and go on unemployment.Maddy wrote: This will kill small business in rural areas--which may, in the end, be exactly what is intended.
Also, Austen, can I ask what types of products are made in the small business you are referring to? Those wages really strike me as low but maybe I need a reality check.
- Austen Heller
- Executive Member
- Posts: 154
- Joined: Tue Aug 24, 2010 6:58 pm
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
I don't think the state has anything at all to gain, the loss of rural manufacturing jobs will just be an unintended consequence. I'm sure the burger flippers in Manhattan will love getting $15/hour though, regardless of how it affects folks upstate.barrett wrote: What does a state really have to gain though by killing small businesses in rural areas?
Also, Austen, can I ask what types of products are made in the small business you are referring to? Those wages really strike me as low but maybe I need a reality check.
For anonymity, I'd rather not tell the exact product. Suffice to say it's a recreational product, so if the prices go up, people will just choose not to buy. As learned in 2008/9, sales are highly correlated to a prosperous economy.
I also thought the wages were low, but these are jobs for people without any degrees, some don't even have a high school diploma. Housing is pretty cheap in a lot of upstate NY areas, $75k can get you a decent house on a quarter acre up there. Having said that, even where I live now (southern Cali.), I know of some young guys who are aspiring to get jobs at an auto dealer, where they can make $10/hour. Of course, these are kids, still living at home and no debts to repay. But sheesh, $10/hour is a tough way to make it through life in CA. You will never move out of your parents' basement at that rate.
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
It's not what the state has to gain, but rather what's to be gained by those who line the lawmakers' pockets. Thinkbarrett wrote: What does a state really have to gain though by killing small businesses in rural areas?
Walmart, for one.
"We are on the verge of a global transformation; all we need is the. . . right major crisis. . . and the nation will accept the. . . new world order." David Rockefeller (1994)
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
My wife's sister and family are visiting from Australia and my brother-in-law reports that they have a $15+ minimum wage in Australia. He also reports that a Big Mac at McDonald's costs $6 (not the meal, just the sandwich). Even worse, a twelve pack of Heineken runs about 30$. He's really enjoying our beer at half the cost.
Re: Minimum Wage Now $15 an Hour!
Are you taking the exchange rate into account? 15 Aussie Dollars would be about $11.40 US at current exchange rates. Of course the Big Mac is still expensive... not to mention the beer (the more painful issue for me personally. One can, after all, live without Big Macs).curlew wrote: My wife's sister and family are visiting from Australia and my brother-in-law reports that they have a $15+ minimum wage in Australia. He also reports that a Big Mac at McDonald's costs $6 (not the meal, just the sandwich). Even worse, a twelve pack of Heineken runs about 30$. He's really enjoying our beer at half the cost.