Good point and I think Biden's response was handled no better than Trump's white supremacy response. As I recall he said something on the order of, "of course I believe in law" but left out the word "order" which seemed kind of strange. Not sure what point he was even trying to make.vnatale wrote: ↑Fri Oct 02, 2020 4:26 pmWhat's been missing in this discussion is Trump doing the same when he was badgering Biden about saying Trump's exact words regarding "Law and Order". I believe that Biden responded by saying, "Yes, I believe in law and order and [something else]. Therefore, Trump could have given some form of answer to the question as posed to him.pp4me wrote: ↑Fri Oct 02, 2020 3:33 pmThere is no lack of advice to Trump about what he should have said but I would offer "Are you also going to ask me next if I've stopped beating my wife, Chris? I've already condemned white supremacists on many occasions and I don't need to do it again".Tortoise wrote: ↑Thu Oct 01, 2020 4:53 pmYes. Scott Adams actually discussed this in more detail in today's show, and he pointed out that asking an opponent in a debate to say something using a specific phrase (in this case, "I disavow white supremacists") rather than in their own words is a power move. Whatever the phrase is, if the opponent says it as requested, it makes him look weaker than the other guy. It reduces his perceived power.pp4me wrote: ↑Thu Oct 01, 2020 4:20 pm The white supremacist question was nothing more than a "have you stopped beating your wife" gotcha kind of question that served no purpose other than to tie Trump to white supremacy.
[...]
I'm guessing Trump thinks to himself they should take the white supremacy question and stick it up their you know what because he knows very well how the game is played by now.
Trump is an expert at the persuasion game, so he knows all about power dynamics. So he would probably never parrot a specific phrase demanded by his opponent, even if the phrase is something he agrees with 100%.
Vinny
Big difference to me is that the headline in the next day's news cycle was all about Trump's response and not Biden's. Nothing unexpected about that, of course. Just par for the course.
Also, Trump had to pose the "gotcha" questions because he knew Chris Wallace wasn't going to do it. At least that was my observation.